call: 260.442.3663
Call Us
Wait please...

East Haven Tavern

YOU ARE HERE : Restaurants » East Haven Tavern
Restaurant Info
LOCATION 635 Green Street
New Haven, IN 46774
Unavailable for delvery ASAP.
Next delivery available today after 11:35am
  • Monday, 11:00am - 3:00am
  • Tuesday, 11:00am - 3:00am
  • Wednesday, 11:00am - 3:00am
  • Thursday, 11:00am - 3:00am
  • Friday, 11:00am - 3:00am
  • Saturday, 11:00am - 3:00am


  • All Items (48)
  • Appetizers (14)
  • Wings (1)
  • Salads (3)
  • Wraps (3)
  • Sandwiches (12)
  • Famous Friday Cod (3)
  • Pizza and Rolls (2)
  • Sides (7)
  • Extra Items (3)


Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce

Hand Battered Chicken Tenders
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce

Bada Bing Shrimp
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce

Battered Mushrooms
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
Delicious button mushrooms tossed in a beer batter, deep fried golden.

Button mushrooms, baked in our garlic butter and melted 5 blend cheese!

Garlic Cheese Bread

Garlic Knots
Baked knots tossed in creamy butter and roasted garlic

Pepperjack Cheese Balls
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
Tasty cubes of pepperjack cheese dipped in batter and fried to golden perfection.

Mini Chicken Tacos
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
Little chicken tacos fried to perfection. Served with salsa and sour cream upon request.

Onion Petals
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
Petals cut from a jumbo fancy sweet onion. Cooked golden, light and crisp.

Battered Dill Pickles
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
Our yummy dill pickles, beer battered and deep fried.

Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Appetizer - 6pc + dipping sauce
6 Beer battered, creamy white Mozzarella sticks.

Southwest Egg Rolls
Appetizer - Served with sour cream + salsa + sweet and sour sauce
These aren't traditional egg rolls! Flour tortillas stuffed with an exciting blend of our southwestern style ingredients, deep fried to golden brown.

Tater Tots


Priced per wing - Minimum order of 5
Choose from traditional bone-in wings (meaty, crispy, made to order) or boneless wings (generous chunks of chicken breast meat, breaded and fried). Both styles are dipped in your choice of our delicious house-made signature sauces. Minimum order of 5 for each sauce please!


Chef Salad
Salad - Lettuce + tomato + colby + bacon + egg + ham + turkey + breadstick
Lettuce, tomato, Colby cheese, bacon, egg, smoked ham and turkey breast.

Buffalo Chicken Salad
Salad - Lettuce +buffalo chicken + tomato + cheese + breadstick
Lettuce, chicken breast, tossed in mild sauce, tomato and mozzarella cheese.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Salad - Lettuce + chicken + bacon + ranch + colby + tomato + breadstick
Lettuce, tomato, chicken breast, ranch, Colby cheese and crumbled bacon.


Chef Wrap
Wrap -- Lettuce + tomato + Colby + bacon + egg + ham + turkey + 1 side
Lettuce, mixed with tomato, colby cheese, bacon, boiled egg and smothered in ham and smoked turkey breast.

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Wrap - Lettuce +buffalo chicken + tomato + cheese + 1 side
Fresh mixture of lettuce, chicken breast, tossed in our buffalo sauce, tomato and four blend mozzarella cheese.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Wrap - Lettuce + chicken + bacon + ranch + colby + tomato + 1 side
Lettuce, tomato, colby cheese, grilled or breaded chicken breast topped with crumbled bacon.


Fried Bologna Sandwich
A thick sliced hunk of deli bologna deep fried to a dark golden brown.

Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
Sandwich - Philly meat + green pepper + onion + Swiss chese
Philly meat, grilled green peppers and onions smothered in swiss cheese on a lightly toasted bun.

Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Sandwich - Choice of prep style
Breaded or Grilled. Our customers favorite! A butcher quality tenderloin, big, breaded and fried to a golden brown on a toasted bun.

Ham and Swiss Sandwich
Deli-style smoked ham, smothered in Swiss cheese on a toasted sub bun.

Cheese Griller Sandwich
Sandwich - Pepper jack + Swiss + American on Texas toast

Chicken Breast Sandwich
Sandwich - Choice of prep style
Fresh chicken breaded or grilled to order.

Burger - 1/4 lb

Mushroom and Swiss Burger
Burger - 1/4 lb + mushrooms + Swiss cheese

Patty Melt Sandwich
Sandwich - 1/2 lb beef patty + Swiss cheese + onions + rye bread
A quarter pound patty smothered in swiss cheese and grilled onions on top quality toasted rye bread.

Bleu Cheese Burger
Burger - 1/2 lb + bacon + Swiss cheese + Blue cheese
Quarter pound patty, topped with bacon, Swiss and Bleu cheese.

Jalapeno Burger
Burger - 1/4lb + onion + pepper jack + jalapeno
A quarter pounder, grilled with kickin spices, covered in grilled onion, pepperjack cheese and jalapenos on a toasted bun.

East Haven Burger
Burger - 2 - 1/4 lb patties + 4 slices American cheese - topped with coleslaw
Two fresh butcher-delivered quarter pound patties, with four slices of American cheese and topped with our homemade coleslaw on a toasted bun.

Famous Friday Cod

Famous Friday Cod Sammy
Friday Only - Fish sandwich + 1 side

Famous Friday Cod Basket
Friday Only - 1/2 lb + 2 sides

Famous Friday Cod Dinner
Friday Only - 1lb + 2 sides

Pizza and Rolls

Cheese Pizza
Additional topping available

Sausage Roll
Additional toppings available - Served with BBQ


French Fries

Cole Slaw
Made fresh in house. Sweet, tangy and full of flavor.

Potato Salad
Made fresh in house. Idaho potatoes, mustard, mayo, onion and pepper and few other special ingredients make this one of our most delicious sides.

Macaroni Salad
Made fresh in house. Creamy, fresh vegetables, al dente macaroni.

Cottage Cheese

Tossed Salad
Side - Lettuce + tomato + cheese
Lettuce, tomato and a sprinkle of shredded cheese.

Soup of the Day
Soup - Call for selection
© 2023 Waiter on the Way, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Home Terms of Service Privacy Policy Refund Policy