Waiter on the Way Food Delivery, Delivering Now, From Restaurants Near You

call: 260.442.3663
Menu
Call Us
260-442-3663
Your delivery address:

Wait please...

East Haven Tavern

YOU ARE HERE : Restaurants » East Haven Tavern
  • NEW HAVEN
Restaurant Info
LOCATION 635 Green Street
New Haven, IN 46774
Available for delivery ASAP
HOURS
  • Monday, 11:00am - 3:00am
  • Tuesday, 11:00am - 3:00am
  • Wednesday, 11:00am - 3:00am
  • Thursday, 11:00am - 3:00am
  • Friday, 11:00am - 3:00am
  • Saturday, 11:00am - 3:00am
PRINTABLE MENU click

Menu

Categories
  • All Items (75)
  • Appetizers (15)
  • Burgers (8)
  • Sandwiches (7)
  • Wraps (3)
  • Salads and Soup (4)
  • Wings (4)
  • Pizza and Rolls (9)
  • Sides (8)
  • Sweets (1)
  • Friday Fish (13)
  • Extra Items (3)

Appetizers


Angry Monkey Balls
Appetizer -

Buffalo Chicken Dip
Appetizer - Served with chips
$8.75

Tater Tots
Appetizer - Choice of size
$4.99

Battered Mushrooms
Appetizer - Served with ranch
$9.99
Delicious button mushrooms tossed in a beer batter, deep fried golden.

Bada Bing Shrimp
Appetizer - Served with onion + lettuce + bada bing sauce
$14.99

Battered Dill Pickles
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
$9.99

Bavarian Pretzels with Cheese
Appetizer - 3 pc - Served with cheese sauce
$11.25
Soft pretzels, baked to golden brown and lightly dusted with pretzel salt.

Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Appetizer - 6pc + dipping sauce
$9.99
6 Beer battered, creamy white Mozzarella sticks.

Chicken Tenders
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
$11.25

Pepperjack Cheese Balls
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
$10.60
Tasty cubes of pepperjack cheese dipped in batter and fried to golden perfection.

Garlic Cheese Bread
Appetizer
$9.99

Gizzards
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
$11.25

Onion Petals
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
$9.99
Petals cut from a jumbo fancy sweet onion. Cooked golden, light and crisp.

Mini Chicken Tacos
Appetizer - Served with dipping sauce
$10.60
Little chicken tacos fried to perfection. Served with salsa and sour cream upon request.

Crinkle Fry Basket
Appetizer
$6.89

Burgers


Smash Burger
Burgers - Small burger + grilled onion + pickle + served with fries
$10.69

Hamburger
Burger
$8.19

Cheeseburger
Burger - Quarter-pound patty with pepper jack, swiss, or American cheese.
$9.99

Bleu Cheese Burger
Burger - 1/4 lb + bacon + Swiss cheese + Blue cheese
$14.99
Quarter pound patty, topped with bacon, Swiss and Bleu cheese.

East Burger
Burger - 2 - 1/4 lb patties + 4 slices American cheese - topped with coleslaw
$17.09
Two fresh butcher-delivered quarter pound patties, with four slices of American cheese and topped with our homemade coleslaw on a toasted bun.

Jalapeno Burger
Burger - 1/4lb + onion + pepper jack + jalapeno
$12.19
A quarter pounder, grilled with kickin spices, covered in grilled onion, pepperjack cheese and jalapenos on a toasted bun.

Mushroom and Swiss Burger
Burger - 1/4 lb + mushrooms + Swiss cheese
$11.89

Patty Melt
Burger - 1/4 lb beef patty + Swiss cheese + onions + rye bread
$12.19
A quarter pound patty smothered in swiss cheese and grilled onions on top quality toasted rye bread.

Sandwiches


BLT
Sandwich
$11.29

Cheese Griller Sandwich
Sandwich - Your choice of 2 cheeses
$8.79

Philly Sandwich
Sandwich - Choice of Steak or Chicken + green pepper + onion + Swiss cheese
$13.79
Philly meat, grilled green peppers and onions smothered in swiss cheese on a lightly toasted bun.

Hot Ham and Cheese Sub
Sandwich
$12.49
Deli-style smoked ham, smothered in Swiss cheese on a toasted sub bun.

Tenderloin Sandwich
Sandwich - Choice of grilled or fried
$12.49
Breaded or Grilled. Our customers favorite! A butcher quality tenderloin, big, breaded and fried to a golden brown on a toasted bun.

Fried Bologna Sandwich
Sandwich
$11.89
A thick sliced hunk of deli bologna deep fried to a dark golden brown.

Hot Italian Sub
Sandwich
$14.99

Wraps


Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Wrap - Lettuce +buffalo chicken + tomato + cheese + 1 side
$16.29
Fresh mixture of lettuce, chicken breast, tossed in our buffalo sauce, tomato and four blend mozzarella cheese.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Wrap - Lettuce + chicken + bacon + ranch + colby + tomato + 1 side
$16.29
Lettuce, tomato, colby cheese, grilled or breaded chicken breast topped with crumbled bacon.

Chef Wrap
Wrap - Lettuce + tomato + Colby + bacon + egg + ham + turkey + 1 side
$16.29
Lettuce, mixed with tomato, colby cheese, bacon, boiled egg and smothered in ham and smoked turkey breast.

Salads and Soup


Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Salad - Lettuce + chicken + bacon + ranch + colby + tomato + breadstick
$16.29
Lettuce, tomato, chicken breast, ranch, Colby cheese and crumbled bacon.

Chef Salad
Salad - Lettuce + tomato + colby + bacon + egg + ham + turkey + breadstick
$16.29
Lettuce, tomato, Colby cheese, bacon, egg, smoked ham and turkey breast.

House Tossed Salad
Salad - iceberg + spring mix + colby cheese + cucumber + tomato + croutons
$4.99

Chili
$4.99

Wings


5 Wings
$7.89

10 Wings
$15.69

15 Wings
$23.49

20 Wings
$31.29

Pizza and Rolls


Sausage Roll
Additional toppings available - Served with BBQ
$16.29

Cheese Pizza
$17.49

1 Topping Pizza
Choice of toppings
$17.49

2 Topping Pizza
Choice of toppings
$19.39

3 Topping Pizza
Choice of Toppings
$21.29

4 Topping Pizza
Choice of Toppings
$23.19

5 Topping Pizza
Choice of Toppings
$24.99

6 Topping Pizza
Choice of Toppings
$26.89

Sides


Cole Slaw
Side
$4.99
Made fresh in house. Sweet, tangy and full of flavor.

Macaroni Salad
Side
$4.99
Made fresh in house. Creamy, fresh vegetables, al dente macaroni.

Cottage Cheese
Side
$4.99

Potato Salad
Side
$4.99
Made fresh in house. Idaho potatoes, mustard, mayo, onion and pepper and few other special ingredients make this one of our most delicious sides.

Tossed Salad
Side - Lettuce + tomato + cheese
$4.99
Lettuce, tomato and a sprinkle of shredded cheese.

Soup of the Day
Soup - Call for selection
$4.99

Tater Tots
Side.
$4.99

French Fries
Side
$4.99

Sweets


Elaine's Homemade Pie
1 Slice.
$4.39

Friday Fish


Famous Friday Cod Dinner - 1 Pound
Friday Only - 1lb Cod + 1 hot side + 1 cold side + tartar sauce.
$28.79

Famous Friday Cod Basket
Friday Only - 1/2 lb. Cod + 1 hot side + 1 cold side + tartar sauce.
$18.79

Cod Mini
Friday only - 6oz. Cod + 1 side + tartar sauce.
$16.29

Famous Friday Cod Sammy
Friday Only - Fish sandwich + 1 side
$17.49

Famous Friday Cod - Ala Carte
Friday Only - Cod only Choice of size
$14.99

Ala Carte Little Fish (POLLOCK)
Friday Only - 2 pieces pollock only + tartar sauce
$9.99

Ala Carte Big Fish (POLLOCK)
Friday Only - 4 pieces pollock only + tartar sauce
$21.29

Little Fish Platter
Friday only - 2 pieces of pollock + 1 hot side + 1 cold side + tartar sauce.
$14.99

Big Fish Platter
Friday only - 4 pieces of pollock +1 hot side + 1 cold side + tartar sauce.
$21.29

Pollock Sandwich
Friday only - Pollock + toasted bun + 1 side + tartar sauce.
$13.79

Hush Puppies Ala Carte 6 Pc
Friday Only - Hush Puppies
$4.39

Bada Bing Shrimp Lent
Friday Only - Breaded shrimp + bada bing + bed of lettuce + green onion.
$14.99

Coconut Shrimp Dinner
Friday only - Breaded Coconut Shrimp + fries + cold side.
$18.79
© 2025 Waiter on the Way, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Home Terms of Service Privacy Policy Refund Policy