call: 260.442.3663
Menu
Call Us
260-442-3663
Wait please...

Big Apple Pizza

YOU ARE HERE : Restaurants » Big Apple Pizza
  • DOWNTOWN
Restaurant Info
LOCATION 120 W. Wayne Street
Fort Wayne, IN 46808
Unavailable for delvery ASAP.
Next delivery available today after 11:45am
HOURS
  • Tuesday, 11:00am - 8:30pm
  • Wednesday, 11:00am - 8:30pm
  • Thursday, 11:00am - 8:30pm
  • Friday, 11:00am - 8:30pm
  • Saturday, 11:00am - 8:30pm
  • Sunday, 4:00pm - 8:00pm
PRINTABLE MENU click
ABOUT

Growing up in New England, I became used to a certain style of pizza. The “New York style,” as developed by Italian immigrants who settled in The City (as we called New York City), comes with a thin, crispy crust, with not a ton of sauce and sprinkled with delicious, fresh toppings. The crust is thin enough to fold in half, which is the accepted way of eating a slice as you walk through Times Square.

You don’t see that style much in the heartland. I’m happy to report that real New York-style pizza has come to Fort Wayne, housed in Big Apple Pizza on Wells Street. Co-owners Chad Castator and Patrick O’Sullivan have developed their pizzas to reflect the New York style, complete with foldability.

The pair met while working together at Club Soda, which bought Richard’s Bakery several years ago to provide a space for the restaurant to prepare food for catering as well as to provide breads for the restaurant. That venture didn’t work out, but Castator (who was running Club Soda’s catering side) saw the location’s potential. He and O’Sullivan, a New Hyde Park, N.Y., native, thought it was time to bring a taste of the Big Apple to the Summit City. They purchased Richard’s Bakery and decided to open what they’ve dubbed a “bakearizza” – a bakery that sells pizza.

Menu

Categories
  • All Items (67)
  • Appetizer (3)
  • Rolls (6)
  • 16" - Square Crust - New York Style Pizzas (3)
  • 18" - Classic Crust - New York Style Pizzas (14)
  • 24" - Classic Crust - New York Style Pizzas (14)
  • 14" - Gluten Free Pizzas (15)
  • Gluten Free - Crustless Pizza Bowls (4)
  • Vegan Pizzas (4)
  • Dessert (1)
  • Extra (3)

Appetizer


Garlic Knots - Half Order
Appetizer - Served with marinara sauce
$4.99

Garlic Knot - Full Order
Appetizer - Served with marinara sauce
$6.99

Cheesy Garlic Breadsticks
Appetizer - 10pc - Served with marinara sauce
$10.99

Rolls


Sausage Roll
$12.99
Sausage, ,mozzarella, onion, green peppers and our traditional New York style pizza sauce served on the side. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Pepperoni, mozzarella and our traditional New York style pizza sauce. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham and our traditional New York style pizza sauce. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Chicken cutlets, breaded and fried with mozzarella and out traditional New York style pizza sauce. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Chicken cutlets drenched in our own buffalo sauce, mozzarella and a side of ranch. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Chicken cutlets drenched in our house ranch dressing with bacon and mozzarella cheese. Add your favorite topping for an additional charge.

16" - Square Crust - New York Style Pizzas


Brooklyn Sicilian Pizza
16" - Square Pizza Crust - marinara + oregano + mozzarella + parmesan
$26.99
A deep dish, focaccia style crust with slow-cooked house marinara, shredded mozzarella cheese, parmesan and oregano.

Queens Grandma Pizza
16" - Square Pizza Crust - garlic + basil + mozzarella
$20.99
Our delicious homemade chunky tomato sauce with garlic, fresh-cut basil, and fresh mozzarella on a square thin crust

Drunken Grandma Pizza
16" - Square Pizza Crust - vodka sauce + garlic + basil + mozzarella
$25.99
Grandma got into the liquor cabinet! We use our homemade vodka sauce on square crust and top with garlic, fresh-cut basil, and fresh mozzarella

18" - Classic Crust - New York Style Pizzas


Manhattan Neapolitan Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - tomato sauce + mozzarella
$19.99
Topped with Mozzarella and our homemade tomato sauce. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Vodka Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - vodka sauce + cheese
$20.99
Our traditional cheese pizza with a twist-instead of using our traditional red sauce, our delicious vodka sauce.

Long Island White Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - traditional sauce + ricotta + parmesan
$27.99
A cheese lover's dream! We start with our traditional sauce, top with premium ricotta, and sprinkle in our Parmesan cheese!

FDNY Buffalo Chicken Pizza
18 " - Classic Crust - chicken + buffalo sauce + mozzarella
$27.99
Our fresh-cut chicken seasoned with our secret recipe goes on top of our fresh mozzarella. We then top with our homemade buffalo sauce. Pairs great with a side of ranch.

Staten Island Meat Lovers Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - pepperoni + sausage + ham + bacon + mozzarella
$27.99
This is what a carnivore's dreams are made of! We start off with our fresh mozzarella. Then the fun begins: fresh pepperoni, link-style sausage that we slice in-house, ham, and of course...BACON.

NYPD Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - chicken + bacon + ranch
$27.99
A fan favorite! Our house-seasoned secret ingredient chicken with bacon and topped with our homemade creamy ranch.

Rotten Apple Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - vodka sauce + ricotta + parmesan
$27.99
A Big Apple Pizza classic! We start with our homemade creamy vodka sauce and dabble on our delicious premium ricotta cheese. We then sprinkle in Parmesan cheese. A fan favorite!

Supreme Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - pepperoni + sausage + onion + mushroom + green pepper + cheese
$27.99
Give me the works! Fresh pepperoni, sliced sausage, and fresh cut vegetables (onion, mushroom, green pepper) all go on top of our fresh mozzarella sauce. If you can’t decide between a meat pizza or a veggie pizza, why not have both?

Margarita Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - tomato + basil + mozzarella + parmesan
$27.99
An Italian classic! Our fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh tomato, and freshly sliced basil are topped with Parmesan.

Hell's Kitchen Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - mozzarella + garlic + ricotta + parmesan
$27.99
Our traditional Manhattan Neapolitan cheese pizza with a twist! We start with our mozzarella, then dabble on our delicious ricotta cheese, garlic, and topped off by sprinkling Parmesan on the top. We’ll take you to Heaven with Hell’s Kitchen!

Chicken Parmesan Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - chicken + mozzarella + parmesan
$27.99
Our chicken and secret seasoning goes on top of our mozzarella cheese, topped with Parmesan.

Betty White Margarita Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - ricotta + tomato + basil + mozzarella + parmesan
$27.99
Our traditional margarita pizza with a twist: we put our famous fresh ricotta cheese with tomato, fresh-cut basil, and sprinkle with Parmesan

Drunk Margarita
18" - Classic Crust - vodka sauce + red sauce + mozzarella + basil
$27.99
Topped with Mozzarella and our homemade tomato sauce. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Vodka Garden Pizza
18" - Classic Crust - vodka sauce + tomato + onion + green pepper + mushroom + garlic + basil + cheese
$27.99
Topped with Mozzarella and homemade vodka sauce. Add your favorite toppings for additional charge.

24" - Classic Crust - New York Style Pizzas


Manhattan Neapolitan Pizza
24" - Classic Crust - tomato sauce + mozzarella
$27.00
Topped with Mozzarella and our homemade tomato sauce. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Vodka Pie
24" - Classic Crust- vodka sauce + cheese
$28.99
Our traditional cheese pizza with a twist-instead of using our traditional red sauce, our delicious vodka sauce.

Long Island White Pizza
24" - Classic Crust - traditional sauce + ricotta + parmesan
$42.99
A cheese lover's dream! We start with our traditional sauce, top with premium ricotta, and sprinkle in our Parmesan cheese!

FDNY Buffalo Chicken Pizza
24" - Classic Crust - chicken + buffalo sauce + mozzarella
$42.99
Our fresh-cut chicken seasoned with our secret recipe goes on top of our fresh mozzarella. We then top with our homemade buffalo sauce. Pairs great with a side of ranch.

Staten Island Meat Lovers Pizza
24" - Classic Crust- pepperoni + sausage + ham + bacon + mozzarella
$42.99
This is what a carnivore's dreams are made of! We start off with our fresh mozzarella. Then the fun begins: fresh pepperoni, link-style sausage that we slice in-house, ham, and of course...BACON.

NYPD Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
24" - Classic Crust- chicken + bacon + ranch
$42.99
A fan favorite! Our house-seasoned secret ingredient chicken with bacon and topped with our homemade creamy ranch.

Rotten Apple Pizza
24" - Classic Crust- vodka sauce + ricotta + parmesan
$42.99
A Big Apple Pizza classic! We start with our homemade creamy vodka sauce and dabble on our delicious premium ricotta cheese. We then sprinkle in Parmesan cheese. A fan favorite!

Supreme Pizza
24" - Classic Crust- pepperoni + sausage + onion + mushroom + green pepper + cheese
$42.99
Give me the works! Fresh pepperoni, sliced sausage, and fresh cut vegetables (onion, mushroom, green pepper) all go on top of our fresh mozzarella sauce. If you can’t decide between a meat pizza or a veggie pizza, why not have both?

Margarita Pizza
24" - Classic Crust- tomato + basil + cheese
$42.99
An Italian classic! Our fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh tomato, and freshly sliced basil are topped with Parmesan.

Hell's Kitchen Pizza
24" - Classic Crust - mozzarella + garlic + ricotta + parmesan
$42.99
Our traditional Manhattan Neapolitan cheese pizza with a twist! We start with our mozzarella, then dabble on our delicious ricotta cheese, garlic, and topped off by sprinkling Parmesan on the top. We’ll take you to Heaven with Hell’s Kitchen!

Chicken Parmesan Pizza
24" - Classic Crust- chicken + mozzarella + parmesan
$42.99
Our chicken and secret seasoning goes on top of our mozzarella cheese, topped with Parmesan.

Betty White Margarita Pizza
24" - Classic Crust - ricotta + tomato + basil + mozzarella + parmesan
$42.99
Our traditional margarita pizza with a twist: we put our famous fresh ricotta cheese with tomato, fresh-cut basil, and sprinkle with Parmesan

Drunk Margarita Pizza
24" - Classic Crust - vodka sauce + red sauce + mozzarella + basil
$42.99
Topped with Mozzarella and our homemade tomato sauce. Add your favorite toppings for an additional charge.

Vodka Garden Pizza
24" - Classic Crust - vodka sauce + tomato + onion + green pepper + mushroom + garlic + basil + cheese
$42.99
Topped with Mozzarella and homemade vodka sauce. Add your favorite toppings for additional charge.

14" - Gluten Free Pizzas


Manhattan Neapolitan - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - tomato sauce + mozzarella
$18.99
Classic cheese pizza on our 14" gluten-free crust. Add your favorite toppings. All gluten free pizzas come on a 14" rice flour crust.

Vodka Pie - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - vodka sauce + cheese
$23.99
Cheese Pizza with Homemade Vodka Sauce

Long Island White - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - traditional sauce + ricotta + parmesan
$23.99
Mozzarella Cheese, Ricotta & Parmesan. All gluten free pizzas come on a 14" rice flour crust.

FDNY Buffalo Chicken - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - chicken + buffalo sauce + mozzarella
$23.99
Red Sauce, Buffalo Sauce, Shredded Mozzarella, Chicken

Staten Island Meat Lovers - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - pepperoni + sausage + ham + bacon + mozzarella
$23.99
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, Ham & Bacon. All gluten free pizzas come on a 14" rice flour crust.

NYPD Chicken Bacon Ranch - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - chicken + bacon + ranch
$23.99
Homemade Ranch, Shredded Mozzarella, Chicken, Bacon

Rotten Apple - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - vodka sauce + ricotta + parmesan
$23.99
Vodka Sauce, Ricotta & Garlic. All gluten free pizzas come on a 14" rice flour crust.

Supreme - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - pepperoni + sausage + onion + mushroom + green pepper + cheese
$23.99
Onion, Green Pepper, Mushroom, Pepperoni & Sausage. All gluten free pizzas come on a 14" rice flour crust.

Margarita - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - tomato + basil + mozzarella + parmesan
$23.99
Chunky tomato sauce topped with fresh mozzarella & basil. All gluten free pizzas come on a 14" rice flour crust.

Hell's Kitchen - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - mozzarella + garlic + ricotta + parmesan
$23.99
Classic cheese pizza topped with ricotta & garlic. All gluten free pizzas come on a 14" rice flour crust.

Chicken Parmesan - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - chicken + mozzarella + parmesan
$23.99
Red Sauce, Shredded Mozzarella, Mushroom, Green pepper, Onion, Pepperoni, Italian Sausage.

Spicy Boi- Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - Hot sauce + red pepper + garlic + banana pepper + jalapeno + chili honey + mozzarella
$23.99
Hot Sauce, Crushed Red Pepper, Shredded Mozzarella, Garlic, Banana Peppers, Jalapenos, Chili-Infused Honey. All gluten free pizzas come on a 14" rice flour crust.

Betty White Margarita - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - ricotta + tomato + basil + mozzarella + parmesan
$23.99
Mozzarella, Ricotta, Tomate & Fresh Basil. All gluten free pizzas come on a 14" rice flour crust.

Drunk Margarita - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - vodka sauce + red sauce + mozzarella + basil
$23.99
Homemade Vodka Sauce. Chunky Tomato Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil

Vodka Garden - Gluten Free Pizza
14" - Gluten Free - vodka sauce + tomato + onion + green pepper + mushroom + garlic + basil + cheese
$23.99
Vodka Sauce, Mozzarella, Tomato, Green Pepper, Onion, Garlic, Mushroom & Fresh Basil. All gluten free pizzas come on a 14" rice flour crust.

Gluten Free - Crustless Pizza Bowls


Build Your Own Pizza Bowl
Gluten Free - Choice of toppings
$9.99
For a Gluten Free Option - All your favorite pizza toppings baked in a foil bowl - Classic Cheese or Select your favorite toppings.

Vodka Garden Pizza Bowl
Gluten Free - vodka sauce + tomato + onion + green pepper + mushroom + garlic + basil + cheese
$12.99
For a Gluten Free Option - All your favorite pizza toppings baked in a foil bowl - Sauce, Cheese, Onion, Green Pepper, Mushroom, Garlic, Vodka Sauce & Fresh Basil.

Supreme Pizza Bowl
Gluten Free - pepperoni + sausage + onion + mushroom + green pepper + cheese
$12.99
For a Gluten Free Option - All your favorite pizza toppings baked in a foil bowl - Sauce, Green Pepper, Onion, Mushroom, Pepperoni and Italian Sausage.

Chicken Parm Pizza Bowl
Gluten Free - chicken + mozzarella + parmesan
$12.99
For a Gluten Free Option - All your favorite pizza toppings baked in a foil bowl - Sauce, Chicken, Cheese, Parmesan.

Vegan Pizzas


Vegan Cheese Pizza - 18"
18" - Vegan Cheese Pizza
$23.99
Traditional cheese pizza made with vegan mozzarella shreds. Add your favorite toppings.

Vegan Cheese Pizza - 24"
24" - Vegan Cheese Pizza
$31.99
Traditional cheese pizza made with vegan mozzarella shreds. Add your favorite toppings.

Vegan Meatzza Pizza - 18"
18" - Vegan pepperoni + vegan chorizo + vegan sausage
$29.99
Marinara sauce & vegan mozzarella shreds topped with vegan pepperoni, vegan chorizo & vegan sausage crumbles.

Vegan Meatzza Pizza - 24"
24" - Vegan pepperoni + vegan chorizo + vegan sausage
$47.99
Marinara sauce & vegan mozzarella shreds topped with vegan pepperoni, vegan chorizo & vegan sausage crumbles.

Dessert

© 2023 Waiter on the Way, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Home Terms of Service Privacy Policy Refund Policy